Archives Association Community democracy and civil society Informal and non-formal education Latest Lifelong learning and adult education Social action social change and social reform working mens' clubs

Henry Solly: Origin and Nature of Worker Clubs and Institutes

Graeme Douglas Worker Club. Flickr -ccbysa2 license
Image of Graeme Douglas. Flickr ccbysa2 license

  grabbed the archives

In this chapter, Henry critiques the early improvement of working males's clubs and confirms their key qualities and rules. The publication was first revealed as a publication by Henry Solly (1867; 1904) Staff' Social Clubs and Instructional Institutions

  Henry Solly The founder and great propagandist of club and institute clubs, Henry Solly (1813-1903) provided much needed conceptual readability for the idea of club work. He was additionally an essential contributor to the enlargement of working class political rights and helped to create a charity association.

On this chapter he appears at the improvement of working males's golf equipment and instructional establishments and develops some key themes. These embrace the importance of dialogue and social change, group, schooling and self-government. He commented: “A free and easy society, without the presence of masters or teachers, is the first and absolutely indispensable condition for the club's life and usefulness. But shame on a club that has nothing to do with it! ”(Page 46).

hyperlinks: Henry Solly and the Staff' Membership and Institute Association; Henry Solly's brochure for the Staff' Club and Institute Affiliation 1862


[page 21] In tracing the origins and character of the current motion of the worker's golf equipment and institutes, we now have to take a look at forty years as a true good friend of the working class, Dr. Birkbeck; and to which the famous man, who has led the van in so many giant corporations for the profit of mankind, gave such a particular assist to the Lord Brougham. This unrest was purely instructional work that was initially meant to teach mechanics the right info and rules of their very own trades. Then there were numerous indirect intermittent makes an attempt to offer the workers referred to as "reading rooms", the place the primary factor was the place where innocent passage of time, but without training, social relationship or recreation, besides if reading a newspaper or guide in the same room with others with individuals might assume that it allows every thing or either. Subsequent, there were mutual enchancment corporations that met mainly within the faculty rooms and have been geared in the direction of courses, discussions, and especially getting ready brief magazines for fascinating and therapeutic subjects. These small organizations typically had [page 22] quite a bit of social life, but they have been not often long-lived. In 1842, the writer set up a broader plan for males normally working in Yeovil, Somersetshire, who seek consensus for mutual profit in some ways, however primarily in educating. and with none club features proper. It was very appreciated and very helpful for a while, however when he left the town, dishonest practices have been broken. In the same yr, this wonderful institute, Sheffield People Excessive Faculty, was based by a very critical and capable good friend of the individuals, Late Rev. RL Bayly, who has executed good there, and continues to be there.

But the biggest impulse to assist working men in the path they’re now taking a look at, where everyone was involved in the national nature, after the launch of the mechanical amenities, was given. FW Robertson, Trinity Church, Brighton, based in 1849 by Brighton Worker Institute. The good hearts of this gentleman, the Christian sympathies, and his hanging expression appeal to considerable attention to his firm; its impact felt by way of the provinces of Midland and as far north as South Shields, where the employee's institute was founded quickly after the lads who had heard vaguely a few factor that was good for working individuals and thought it might do the same in their very own locality. Their institute has continued its healthy and useful existence to the current day. The more direct and recognized impulse of the middle of the Church was given in several different towns where institutes for the employee have been established, and amongst others for some working men and their associates, including the writer, in Cheltenham, where in 1849-50 a worker's institute was set as much as mix schooling and leisure with a prototype. however [page 23] who later fell into dangerous arms and was closed to honor.

Establishing and establishing nightclubs The promotion of grownup schooling in the Yorkshire and Lancashire Unions, the Southern counties, the South Staffordshire and the Metropolitan Society has been a helpful company for the last ten years in working class schooling, but the good work achieved has primarily been for young individuals, and the results are usually not passable for these in work. for men.

Though all these efforts have yielded more than much less indisputable profit, none of them have fulfilled what’s undoubtedly the primary great want of the workforce after their long days – ie limitless social interplay, a way of discussing with each other, with or without refreshments. This is the primary and simplest rest that hard-working males stay in line with their needs. but with respect to religious culture and educated taste there’s of course a want for other pleasures than mere conversation. All the efforts which are acutely aware to help staff who usually are not instantly of their ethical, spiritual or monetary well-being have ignored this main and simplest but most urgent want. Because of this, their success could be very restricted. A number of working class elites benefited from them here and there. However they never obtained to the plenty who nonetheless found the only circumstances that they had expected in a public home the place they had to pay it in a approach that they didn't all the time want – all the time – in all occasions., Consuming "for the good of the house" and their households and themselves.

Nevertheless, the above yr (1852) appears to be a brand new aspect. We have been informed that this yr the establishment was opened in the Clare market, beneath the leadership of Viscount Ingestre, referred to as "Colonnade Working Men & # 39; s Club", and entertainment and [page 24] recreation, including newspapers and books, although it doesn't seem fairly certain when it actually started. Nevertheless, it continued until lately and met a suitable quantity of help;

Laudable, however because this improved system was, it doesn't seem to attract common consideration. Horlock Bastard, Charlton Marshall, near Blandford, Dorset, based in 1855 a village laborers' club, which continues to pursue a humble utility career, and, like Colonnade London's club, mixed with opportunities for refreshments, the first target – newspapers, books, chess and sketches, while was provided. Ladies may be members of the Charlton Membership. An identical village membership was founded at the similar time in Hertfordshire, owned by Mr Lawes, together with garden provides. The small quantity of beer bought was bought to this club to members that resulted in the closure of the public home. Shortly thereafter, village clubs have been established in Littlemore and Iffley in Oxfordshire, which once more attracted golf equipment in Kingham, Chipping Norton and Adderbury, Oxon.

Then, one of the greatest impulses, though not the greatest, but given, this nation moves to boost working males on a social scale. It is meant that Rev. In 1854, F. Maurice and his actual co-workers founded the School of London Staff. This most essential firm emerged from the "Christian Socialist or Cooperative" movement that had recognized and raised the hopes by which these gentlemen had previously been concerned; however the identify and concept of ​​the school, Mr Maurice says, the Sheffield People High Faculty advised to him, which is an admirable institution, however it has been a bit greater than a capital class system

[page 25] "The Hearts and English Hands" by Miss Marsh despite the fact that they didn’t declare a separate place to boost the workgroups with the assistance of social or instructional institutions, they gave such great encouragement to those efforts and to the center and higher class sympathies with the "holy boys" that it might be a critical neglect if it was not discovered right here. Probably the most direct and putting results of this publication have been that Wightman was involved in leading Christian work at Shrewsbury i86o, which has released a spacious and handsome Employee Corridor as a tangible agency. and unexpectedly moral and religious good for men in that metropolis and elsewhere. There is a very thriving Temperance Society that meets in Hall. But there doesn’t appear to be anything just like the worker's club working there.

In 1858, about 4 years after the establishment of a labor faculty, priest in Salford, Rev. E. Boteler Chalmer founded the Labor Club, which made social intercourse, amusements and refreshments a priority. It has been very useful and successful

In 1860, two wonderful ladies in several elements of the metropolis, who didn’t find out about one another, however both went into motion to prove the suffering and degradation of the wives and the youngsters of the labor. The lads they have been interested by have been busy ways to attract these males from a public house. Through the yr, z86o, Miss Adeline Cooper, succeeded in putting in the amenities for Duck-lane, Westminster, which was suitable for the item he saw, and after December, the Westminster Worker Club was officially opened in December. Thankfully, Miss Cooper saw the value and importance of calling the institute, the membership thus established, and bringing the writer to the identical view, has been a serious assist in strengthening the fitting identify for both these societies and mobility. Usually – not just a little service, in comparison with how much the rationale depends upon success in its identify. When names are symbols, their power is immeasurable. The Duck-lane club has continued to be humble but still an important utility to this present day. In the same yr (1860), Mrs Bayly organized several fascinating conferences with Nottingdal's brickmakers; and in 1861, the Notting Hill Workmen's Hall was opened in Kensington Potteries. For more info on the history and advantages of these pioneering golf equipment, see the totally different numbers of the weekly document (Tweedie); also a very fascinating paper, learn by Mrs Bayly in 1862, the summary of which was revealed in the social science business of that yr, p. 527. They have been each nearly male clubs within the sense that they are now literal – ie laborers who are created to promote social intercourse, innocent amusements, religious improvement, and numerous varieties of mutual help; and their creation, extensively recognized amongst modest innovators, each weekly and by way of Mrs Bayly's personal publications, gave a robust impetus to efforts and analysis in this course. The Manchester company and Mrs. Bayly led the writer within the 1860s to think about whether adding a membership factor to such societies can be for religious improvement, as he had beforehand sought to advertise elsewhere. The temperature reform had long attracted attention and actively supported a number of critical associates within the working courses, nevertheless it was the efforts of Mrs Bayly and Miss Cooper who first led her to see what was undoubtedly needed and might easily ship to make this great reform completely efficient and mixed with larger influence and assistance steadily from an unbiased general commitment.

At about the identical time the writer, who was twenty years [page 27]had tried across the nation to promote Mechanics and Worker Institutes, concluded that rather more recreation and social intercourse than these institutes have been required to satisfy the wants of working men. Having labored for most of the time in the Temperance movement and seeing what number of regenerated drunkards dropped back into his previous ways, he began to comprehend that by far the larger number of males who typically use public homes there for a enterprise and not for a drink. And when a lady who was dedicated to Lancaster's working males, she observed one night time in a pleasing social celebration in a well-heated and illuminated drawing that a pal had written to her solely that day, "The cry comes from all parts of the earth. What are we doing with regenerated drinks?" "A new vision of the work of industrial classes was introduced in his mind. He had been trying for two years to get the workers to participate in the Institute of Mechanics, which had a capital, in Lancaster, but without success, and now he got several residents who dealt with the whole question at two meetings in Townhall (June 1860). Since he was interested in Mr Maurice's work, his first idea was to try to set up a worker's college, which also combines the attractions of a recreation and social association as part of its component. But he soon discovered that the "School" identify rejected virtually all the lads he had been interested within the system to date, and even more of what he needed to attract from the general public home. After several meetings and conferences, a “Workers Mutual Improvement and Recreational Association” was shaped, which flourished strongly and with very useful outcomes for a few yr and a half till it adapted to the favorable circumstances with mechanics "The Institute. At concerning the time, WT [page 28] Marriott, Esq, was set up In the palms of the author, following the needs and assertions of the working teams, Marriott instructed establishing clubs for males on the same basis as within the higher courses. He had been actively concerned in establishing a metropolitan labor institute in Manchester, the place he had arrange a health club, and was undoubtedly within the viewer at Chalmer in Salford. 19659005] In the summer of 1861, when he visited London and talked to Brixton Decide David Thomas, the writer stated that the gentleman is so fascinated with working in locations which are appropriate for himself for men and in search of exactly the identical path. Thomas urged the importance of urgent and nationwide action on this case to propose the formation of a limited firm with a capital of three,000,000 liters. The writer, with great gratitude, saw that such a corporation, if only accomplished as a philanthropic society as an alternative of a business company, was precisely what was required; and Thomas accepted the change, they decided to work immediately to create a brochure and type a membership. Mr Brougham's consent to grow to be its president; and this irreplaceable help, as soon as it has been secured, was made potential by other main males in succession. Next, the writer drew up a paper (“A Look at Workers Wanted”), which he learn from S. A. Steinthal at a gathering of the Social Science Association in Dublin that yr; but because of the threatening Lancashire plight, it was thought-about fascinating that no additional action ought to be taken. In June 1862, the meeting of this association in London introduced an excessively favorable alternative to lose, and a author who had beforehand raised the difficulty of the Pregnancy Conference of the Priestesses and the London Café Ministers was introduced there. Thomas Thomas J. Rylancelle, Curate [page 29] St. Paul, Lambeth. With this very mild help of the gentleman, he irritated the matter in a number of elements of the association (a big quantity of brochures have been distributed at the similar time) and acquired Lord Brougham's in depth assent to the chair at the meeting to launch the proposed society. This meeting was held in the Regulation Association's rooms, Waterloo, on June 14, 1862, when John Bainbridge, the upholsterer, and Mr. Bebbington made two very gifted and fascinating speeches. , Head and Secretary of the Worker's Membership, which has already been talked about, in Duck-lane, Westminster. At this assembly, the congregation was properly opened within the identify of "Workers Club and Institute Union", Mr. Rylance and writer have been appointed Honi. Secretaries work. Mr Neill introduced his intention to offer 100l. His funds, Lord Brougham gave 20l. On the spot, and the unrest on it, much stronger progress was made, and it was helped by what Bayly had read together in Social Science conferences and Miss Adeline Cooper's invaluable advisors.

The following autumn, after the Council assembly on 14 June, the writer resigned from the glossary of the English presbyterian chapel, Lancaster, to develop into a paid secretary of the Union for 200 years of salary; The rooms have been taken to 150 by Strand, and its work began fairly in early October of that yr. Its rules and action plans have been subsequently introduced in a brochure extensively circulated all through the dominion.

[the remainder of page 29 and the pages to page 33 contain the prospectus of the Club and Institute Union, 1862 – which is reproduced on a separate page in the archives]

[page 33] These preparations have been made to members of a national group, two Southampton (Mrs. Deacon and Inglis), two buddies of the Associates (W. and R. Westlake), Sir George Pechell and others who have been struck by works by Bayly and Miss Cooper on the weekly report and with comparable needs, had begun within the early 1862s in the city that led to the opening of three labor governments in the summer of that yr and a fourth on a smaller scale within the spring of 1863. A exceptional success for the primary time in these benevolent successes [page 34] was absolutely described in a letter from WC Westlake & # 39; to the morning star, December II, 1862. The next excerpts have been taken: – Three labor halls have been opened in Southampton over the previous yr, situated in the Orchard lane, St. Michael's Square and Northam. They’re designed to work for males and ladies. administration is within the palms of one central and three government committees – the latter being lively men, who’re elected by the members every six months; and the entire number of members is presently 400…

… The halls are opened from six to ten o'clock every weekend and two to nine on Sundays. Refreshments are delivered at a low fastened fee. Smoking is allowed, however the use of intoxicating drinks on the premises is prohibited. There are a large quantity of publications within the tables – five every day and 9 weekly London and provincial papers, and 16 weekly and monthly magazines. and provides fourteen video games in Corridor and a small space. Every Corridor has lecture rooms and writing rooms; and Halls in Orchard and Northam are open in the course of the meal. A trade register is held for the jobseeker. Public readings, recitations, and vocals take place each Wednesday as members take their spouse and household. The required order is one penny every week, and one cost ensures access to all of the halls. Free admission was given the primary month after the opening. The experience of these Halls promoters has brought out very fascinating details. In answer to the question: "Can't beer be sold in Halls, like in other club rooms?" One of the vice presidents writes: "We do not think it is desirable to do so. But only a few of our members are theoretical, and since we sometimes have 150 – i8o men at one time in the hall, it would be too much for one woman to keep order (as she does now easily) if men could have a "final touch" on our premises. do not drink beer, they’re less captivated with investing and much less arguing… We have been typically advised that no one performs in playhouses without beer or betting, and we determined to check the claim, and the outcome up to now is that although our “round alley” has been thrown every night time The encompassing public homes are virtually abandoned, and we are just nearly as good words and good temperament as most others are the other. ”A spherical country that is appropriate for the proper laws, which could be right here, is a very beneficial addition to those clubs, particularly in huge cities the place you work males can't easily get okay rack areas or leisure areas

“The distribution of the first 700 members was as follows: one quarter, 172 have been staff, caretakers, drivers, and so on .; 109 masons, masons and carpenters, and so on .; 103 boiler manufacturers and blacksmiths, and so forth .; 61 shoe machines, curriors, and so forth .; 54 engineers and sailors; 99 artists and mechanics; 26 customization; the remaining have been retailers, agents, drivers, and so on.

“All of the things added to the leisure and career substrate are on an growing scale. There are lecture and writing courses in the corridor, giant elute and vocal courses, a harmonious membership, a profit society and a lending library. Political discussions are excluded. The order is maintained in line with a easy rule, "that every person must be his own police."

The following steps and rules that guided the original supporters of the Union are greatest seen within the following paper extracts read by the present writer on the Social Science Affiliation held in Edinburgh in October 1863. But it might be good to say that Lord Lyttelton, who at Lord Brougham's request turned Vice-President of the Union in October 1862, and since then, has been one of its steepest and most useful supporters, strongly protesting firstly of 1863 about any try and impose restrictions on labor clubs for selling malt drinks to members and a special meeting [page 36]. The outcome was to take away the rule that was initially accredited and which prohibits golf equipment from getting into the Union that let the sale of such alcoholic beverages and replaced the straightforward suggestion in the second paragraph of the aforementioned brochure. Additionally it is desirable to notice that the Opening Meeting emphasized the significance of linking instructional alternatives to this system of all these clubs; and by E.G. Clarken Esq, the identify of the "Institute" was so long that it was half of the "Club" identify, which suggests incorporating this aspect of studying. Because of this, the thought of ​​linking the important elements of the Worker's Club and the Worker's School to the exceptional and comprehensive title of the "Worker's Club and Institute" was the indispensable and very important principle of this motion, which distinguishes it from all different comparable corporations

"The present mobility of the employee's golf equipment and institutes is rising the totally different species to which the working groups of this nation are exposed, firstly, the restricted nature of households, and secondly, their lack of coaching. These two reasons have led them to hunt social intercourse and pastime in a public house to the extent that they’re detrimental to their moral economic well-being. The third evil has been the hug of locations the place they might meet enterprise functions; results in the identical shameful outcomes. Because of this, there are various efforts to offer rooms where they will take pleasure in a social affiliation and smart entertainment, potential religious improvement and business meetings with wealthier courses in their own houses and in numerous public institutions. The institutes of mechanics have executed great things, [page 37] but not often for working males. Clubs and institutes that at the moment are forming so many directions try to ship all the advantages of a public home with out its evil.

”However the establishment of such clubs, and particularly their creation on good rules, typically requires additional stimulus, and recommendation, information and experience are virtually all the time needed. A key propagandistic society, on the one hand, which provides that stimulus to collect and disseminate the outcomes of reflection and experience, appears to be mandatory; a society that can convey the buddies of this movement into useful relationships, and at the similar time gather their financial supply for successive corporations that need financial assist. With a purpose to meet that we would like a union of a employee's club and an institute, which I now have the consideration of formally representing as secretary,

: “The measures we took to implement the above-mentioned gadgets have been, first of all, to offer circulars to the secretaries of numerous mechanical and thermal associations, provincial newspaper editors and individuals recognized to be curious about social improvement, brochure attachment and collaboration in our firm. Then totally different papers and brochures have been prepared in succession and extensively disseminated in response to inquiries, preparation of public conferences or help for local efforts normally. Several thousand copies of these publications have been distributed. But as we attempt to deliver organized activity to the greatest benevolent enthusiasm, we have been completely satisfied that we might solely permanently use this nation for working courses to the extent that our assist inspired and strengthened them to assist themselves; Subsequently, our most necessary objective has been to arouse the interest of working men within the formation, upkeep and management of these golf equipment. Our motto has been "a supplement, not a substitute." And we have now found the workers in each [page 38] course ready for our efforts as quickly as they perceive our plan and rules.

“But the work of men can’t often give these funds themselves, which is probably fortunate because it provides wealthy individuals the chance to boost them and strengthen the bonds of good emotions between totally different courses. From € 25-50, members of a clubhouse with a lease of between € 12 and € 60 are often not guaranteed individually, and few landlords settle for their collective duty. It’ll meet these preliminary costs and provide this warranty, offered financial help is required. When began fairly, golf equipment in huge cities, in smaller cities, could be self-supporting with smart management, and with the willpower of members to pay their contributions recurrently to their friendly or affiliate. One of the golf equipment that was based just lately in Staffordshire, Wednesday, has been determined by our initiative and steerage to be boldly unbiased of any of their richer neighbors, and the secretary knowledgeable me that the second day has been and will hold their resolution. Their clubs acquired 320 members in the summer months by paying a double salary per week, and they paid the prepayment by joining. Revenues have been 17 6 ​​£. 21 / 2p., Value 15 £ 11. 21 / 2p. Wednesbury is at present the only approach we have now grow to be accustomed to the place the club has been utterly unbiased from the outset from the outset. So, generally, how do these essential costs be met?

“The Worker's Club and the Institutional Affiliation have all the time sought to mobilize the required funds to launch these clubs by encouraging native enthusiasm because they’ve felt that such an institution ought to be rooted in sympathies and cherished by the courses of all neighboring nations – to be developed as it was, [page 39] from the soil the place it grows, and it should not be planted there unique

”But once I ask for native help for any specific membership, we all know that the easiest way to get legal help for working men is that they themselves present their want and make good use of it.

“Because of this, we now have been closely depending on the significance of having a public meeting at the start of the district agitation, and of having an advert hoc committee shaped, or quickly after, composed of primarily men working. We’re also wanting ahead to listening to from you, as well as within the type of a letter of intent. Whether or not or not a personal meeting of the general public is a should. However working men typically want counsel and steerage in addition to cash. Furthermore, in an ideal quantity of instances they ask for, or heartily recognize, the necessity for some quantity of supervision at the side of their very own self-government and freedom. They see the need of elementary guidelines, and they typically want that the guardianship of these ought to be positioned past the interference of members of the Membership. Persons additionally who subscribe their money to determine an institution naturally want some guarantee for its objects being faithfully carried out. Therefore one of probably the most troublesome problems has been to reconcile a specific amount of supervision and management with that unbiased motion and self-government usually by the members which we all recognize as so vitally essential. The plan of having two committees, one of gentlemen, and the opposite of working men, or one appointed by honorary members, subscribers, and donors of 10s. and upwards to hold the purse and manage all monetary matters, we consider to be primarily unsound and pernicious. 1st. As a result of it provides rise to jealousy, collisions, and discontent, [page 40] among the members, who feel that they are being treated as youngsters, mistrusted, and disadvantaged of one of an important features of authorities. 2nd. Because it prevents the members from buying expertise in monetary administration, and from studying the right way to make their Membership self-supporting. 3rd. As a result of it checks any want to make it so, and shifts the duty of holding it out of debt from the shoulders of those that are having fun with its benefits to those of wealthy patrons, and thus inevitably tends to pauperize the members. We consider that we have now, to some extent, solved the problem by recommending the appointment of three or four trustees chosen by donors and honorary members who shall hold and expend such donations and subscriptions as their constituents might contribute, and be at the similar time liable for the observance of certain elementary guidelines agreed on by the persons who want to determine the Membership, but which stated trustees could have no proper of interfering additional in its common management, or have something to do with the unusual members subscriptions. Working men are accustomed to the authority of trustees in their Pleasant and different Societies, and don’t feel such management as the above to be in any respect irksome or inconsistent with their rightful liberties. Where the trustees or another parties are answerable for the lease and taxes of the Club-house, it’s, of course, proper and fascinating that they should have the first claim, in the event that they want it upon the current subscriptions, honorary or atypical, and have management over them to that extent. In some instances it might be crucial that each one the funds ought to go direct to the trustees, or individuals guaranteeing lease, and so forth., and that they should vote at monthly meetings such proportion thereof as they find they will afford, to be spent be the managing committee.

“As quickly because the existence and objects of the Union turned recognized, purposes got here to the workplace from numerous elements of the country for recommendation and info, for pecuniary assist, for a go to from the Secretary, or for social influence to assist in awakening an area curiosity for [page 41] the institution of a Club; and from the gratifying success which has hitherto attended our labours, we can’t but hope that our Society is meeting an awesome need of the age, and that we are becoming a not unimportant reality in the history of our country’s social progress. Individuals of rank, of social position, and excessive tradition, a minimum of the the elite of the working men, members of each Church, and sect, and political social gathering, particularly benevolent and completed women, in each quarter of the dominion, have come ahead to welcome and uphold us in our work. Resolutions in favour of our movement have been handed by a minimum of four necessary Conferences of consultant males—viz.: The Annual Convention of Delegates from Mechanics’ Institutes in reference to the Society of Arts, held on the Adelphi, London, final Might; the Annual Convention of the British Temperance League, held at York, in July final; the Annual Conference of the West of England Temperance League, held at Bristol, in August; and the Annual Convention of the South Staffordshire Adult Instructional Society, held at West Bromwich this present month.

“Not to dwell longer on the methods we adopted, or the help we acquired, the instant outcomes are to be seen in the thirty-two Clubs and Institutes we have now been instrumental in establishing within the area of twelve months, containing on a tough calculation about 7,400 members, and, as we have now purpose to hope, in the improved working of about twenty more, which we have now assisted with info, recommendation, and deputations. There are additionally many other Clubs in process of formation, and each week brings us tidings of their establishment by benevolent associates together with the working males in several elements of the nation.

“The rules which we’ve stored steadily in view and advisable to others as the only sound basis on which to determine these institutions have been—

“1st. That they have been to be managed mainly by the working males themselves.

[page 42] “2nd. That they have been to make amenities for social intercourse, amusements, and rational recreation, the primary object.

“3rd. That they have been invariably to purpose also at combining with those amenities a quiet reading-room and courses for many who wished to enhance themselves.

“4th. That they need to purpose at having frequent entertainments, lectures, &c., which is perhaps attended by the wives and daughters of members.

“5th. That no intoxicating drinks, betting, or playing, ought to be allowed on the premises.

“sixth. That boys, and youths underneath the age of eighteen, should not be admitted to membership.

“seventh. That smoking ought to be allowed, however in a separate room if required.

“8th. That the Clubs ought to be not merely locations to which males might go, however Societies to which they should belong.

“9th. That the Clubs ought to be completely unsectarian, socially, politically, and religiously.

“For want of attending to at least one or other of these factors many unfortunate failures have taken place, and eari~est benevolent individuals been discouraged, so that an ideal and typically lasting hindrance has arisen to stop an identical enterprise on wiser rules being attempted once more in the identical locality.

“The need for creating an ésprit de corps, a real spirit of fellowship, I regard as completely indispensable, not merely as an important means for retaining the Clubs in existence, but as a most essential end in itself, to be gained by the establishment of the Clubs.

“Expertise day by day confirms us in our conviction of the knowledge and significance of rigidly preserving the non-sectarian character both of this movement usually and of the person Clubs. They are meant for persons of all sects and events; they occupy a standard ground on which males of probably the most diversified shades of social, spiritual, and political beliefs might meet in pursuit of widespread objects in a friendly spirit and for mutual profit. [page 43] Therefore they need to not be employed as machinery for promoting sectarian views of any variety. Teetotallers can cordially help them as a result of they may tremendously promote sobriety; but they need to not be made into Complete Abstinence Societies; no man have to be excluded from workplace, still less from membership, as a result of he believes himself justified in taking a glass of wine or beer. A member of Pleasant Societies may give them hearty help, because, by providing an alternate as a place of assembly to the public house, they may drastically promote the success and benefits of those worthwhile organizations. A Trades’ Unionist might help these Clubs for the same reasons, but neither will he be committing the Membership to Commerce-society views by belonging to it, nor must he endeavour to convert the Club into a way of implementing those views. Conservatives and Liberals of all shades can promote these Clubs and Institutes, because they promote the overall well-being, morality, and happiness of the working courses, help to dissipate the alienation and misunderstanding typically present between totally different ranks of society, afford opportunities of mutual interchange of benefits and kindly courtesies, are likely to dissipate that ignorance and apathy which foster so fearfully the evils which enlightened politicians of every social gathering labour to remove. Men of all spiritual persuasions may give these Clubs their zealous co-operation, because whatever promotes sobriety, provident habits, health, intelligence, courtesy, self-respect, rational recreation, and mutual helpfulness, is getting ready the best way for larger influences and religious good, in addition to instantly selling many of the objects which all good Christians heartily want to perform.

“Therefore, if sectarianism have to be thus rigorously prevented it is quite clear that the Clubs can’t normally legitimately or safely be used for immediately selling both spiritual or political enchancment, as a result of the members, in virtually all instances, or those who may want to turn out to be members, would differ as to what was fact or enchancment in these instructions, or as to the right individuals for  [page 44] proclaiming that fact. We have to be very cautious, nevertheless, to repel the notion that subsequently individuals joining such establishments thereby show their indifference to spiritual or political fact. As one of our Vice-Presidents, Lord Lyttelton, noticed at our last annual meeting, a man might be a part of the Atheneum, the Carlton, or Reform Membership, without ever being asked what are his spiritual opinions, and he’ll proceed a member of such Club for all his life without in any means promoting, or aiming thereby to advertise, specific spiritual views or spiritual apply, however he can be very a lot astonished if he have been, subsequently, to be advised he belonged to a godless society, or manifested an indifference to religion.

“Generally a Temperance, Co-operative, Mortgage, or Pleasant Society may be shaped among members of the Club, and hold its meetings at suitable occasions on the premises with out giving event for any hostile feeling. So with a Commerce Society, or a prayer-meeting, a spiritual service, or, probably (however this is more doubtful), associations related with issues of public significance. However in all such instances it might be essential to maintain the group thus shaped, and the proceedings related with it, completely unbiased of the organization of the Club, and in strict subordination to the overall consolation, emotions, and needs of the good majority of the members.

“Lastly, the work which now lies before the Society, and which, as I have stated, is growing day by day in magnitude and importance, consists :—

“1. In aiding to provide the impulse, and to awaken the native efforts, requisite for establishing Clubs, and particularly to offer the steerage needful typically for establishing them on sound rules.

“2. In giving recommendation or material assist requisite for sustaining or renovating Clubs already established.

“3. In developing the full capacities of the Clubs for usefulness, doing this especially by means of the organization which unites them together in our central Society.”

[page 45] We’ve got stated that the fellowship or brotherhood of its structure and the completeness of its purpose constituted the speciality and very important concept of a Working Men’s School. However so far as the Clubs are to be a everlasting and powerful aspect within the elevation of the working courses of this country, these will type, as we’ve got additionally stated, their very important drive likewise. We might have Studying-rooms, Night time Faculties, Lectures, Mechanics’ Institutes, Mutual Enchancment Societies, on the one hand, and we might have Recreation Outlets, Speaking and Smoking-rooms, Penny Readings, Live shows, and Free-and-Easys on the opposite. And we might have all or any of these combined underneath one roof, calling the institution a Workmen’s Hall, a Working Males’s Institute, or a Working Males’s Club, and the stated institution, or any of the separate businesses, will undoubtedly do kind of good while it or they continue. However to start out or promote them, nevertheless useful and laudable particularly instances and as preliminary steps, shouldn’t be the actual work now earlier than the social reformers and associates of the working courses of this nation. That work is to help deliver into being organic our bodies with a dwelling soul in every, all forming half of a larger group which must be full of a but larger very important pressure. We would like societies, brotherhoods, inspired with the identical noble concept as that which has been attributed to Working Males’s Schools, aiming at the completest tradition and improvement of the mental, bodily, and religious of the life members which can be potential underneath the given circumstances, but beginning with the humblest and easiest businesses, assembly the precise social needs of the least cultivated, while providing the means of regularly growing cultivation as they could be prepared and ready to receive it. As far as we purpose at less than this, so far as our movement fails to be impressed with this concept, all who put it on the market, we firmly consider, are solely working for a bit of short-term good, and are getting ready successive failures which can exert a disastrous affect on all subsequent efforts for the profit of working males.

[page 46] If all this be true, it is evident that Working Men’s Clubs and Institutes, when rightly constituted, could also be seen as Working Males’s Schools “in the forming,” with the constituent elements in several levels of improvement, as in all rising organizations. The social factor, and subsequent to it that of recreation, should all the time be made the principal features of .a Working Males’s Membership in its earlier levels of existence. Free-and-easy sociability, with none interference of masters or academics, is the very first and absolutely essential condition for the life and usefulness of the Membership. However woe to that club which aims at nothing more! In proportion as working males get hold of snug and roomy houses, and hand over consuming habits, they’ll see their buddies at their very own houses, just as the upper courses do, and the Clubs can be proportionately much less required for social purposes. But their greater uses will all the time be needed; and 100 years therefore the number of Working Men’s Schools will in all probability far exceed that of Working Males’s Clubs.

This view of the matter attributes, will probably be stated, relatively a posh group to what some have fancied, was an very simple affair. Totta. But the greater any existence may be within the scale of creation—the higher its power and the more enduring its life—the extra complicated we discover its organization to be, and the extra full its improvement. This is as true of communities and establishments as of individual beings. There was a stage within the existence of all of us, when, as in the case of sure animalculae, the stomach was the principal and most lively organ in our system; however the legal guidelines of improvement and the principal of progress have carried us to greater and extra good circumstances, not in spite, but in consequence of such partially exaggerated improvement of that organ in infancy. The idea of a Working Mens’ Club—viz., the talking and smoking-room—is straightforward sufficient, and with the recreation division would be the principal function in it for a very long time. However, that basis might nourish and put together for greater [page 47] varieties—will achieve this inevitably, if the Membership lives. On the similar time, when a Club and Institute begins to outgrow the needs and tastes of the lower class of working males in any neighbourhood, one other for purely Club purposes should immediately be shaped, and thus a succession of appropriate businesses for the gradual elevation and tradition, as well as for the fast enjoyment, of the working courses shall be duly offered. All that we insist on is that, in securing the rudimentary, we must not ever lose sight of the higher and final results. If we care just for certain wonderful, however very restricted objects, or for ephemeral and feeble institutions, don’t allow us to hassle ourselves about Working Males’s Clubs and Institutes. Be content material with Adult Night time Faculties, Penny Readings, or Recreation and Refreshment Rooms. If we want to see organizations succesful of completely aiding the working courses to achieve that full culture and humanizing improvement which we have now the very best authority in maintaining they have been created to take pleasure in, then let us accept the perfect normal now provided. We could also be fairly positive ‘that the perfect efforts will fail to succeed in it absolutely. But, until we have now both a true and a lofty ultimate, the truth completed will probably be miserably inferior, each in high quality and permanence, to what we should always otherwise have attained. However, the higher influences will certainly fail to succeed in the good mass of working men until the humbler points of interest and benefits are first provided.

Next to be able to the need for a genial welcome, and for offering points of interest to the Club, comes the necessity, hinted at above, for cherishing and creating the “society” spirit—the necessity of brotherhood, actually—that spirit which has been at the coronary heart of all true civilization and of all profitable company action from the Dark Ages when males had to type leagues for mutual shield. ion by the sword, right down to the age of Friendly, Trade, Temperance, and Co-operative Societies. But to get this spirit of cohesion and of mutual helpfulness in a Working Men’s Membership and Institute, on what are we to [page 48] rely? Individuals who’ve seen the facility with which it has been manifested in Spiritual, Political, Trade, and Temperance organizations, say we by no means can awaken it in these Clubs, because there in no widespread bond of curiosity and sympathy, no motive power robust sufficient to arouse enthusiasm and zeal. Properly, if there’s not— if they’re merely locations the place the members might go for just a little individual or egocentric amusement and relaxation—we grant they never can grow to be actual societies. However then we must equally grant that, in an amazing majority of instances, they’re destined to have however a quick existence. Twenty years hence, in a number of giant cities, they could exist on the same footing as the gentlemen’s West-end Clubs, however they won’t take root now, on that footing, among the many great body of the working courses, nor in all probability at any future time. Can we discover no true and natural dwelling bond of union for them—some principle and object that shall be capable of cherishing and unfolding that divine spirit of fellowship and sympathy which is mightier to bind men together than all their selfishness and discords are to rend them asunder ?—something that shall make them societies to which males might belong, and not merely locations to which they could go? It might be weak and shameful to doubt it.

But it’ll, very in all probability be asked, Why are Clubs for working males to be so much extra difficult, and to goal at so much more, than gentlemen’s Clubs? Evidently as a result of of the distinction in the circumstances and situation of the two courses. The gentlemen who compose the West-end Clubs in London, for probably the most part, have had the means of gaining tolerably complete culture at college and school. They have, moreover, far higher means and leisure for persevering with that culture at house or on the earth, and their occupations typically have extra of a humanizing and instructional character than the mechanical handicrafts of the working man, while their houses admit of that social intercourse and interchange of visits from which the working men, at present, are precluded by their very limited domestic lodging. [page 49] They’re, actually, able to make their Club minister to larger tradition once they be a part of it. Working men, on the contrary, typically need the very culture which alone would make their Membership worthwhile to them. Therefore there’s a far higher quantity of needs requiring to be glad by these Clubs, in the case of the working males, than in that of the gentry. Then again, a proportionately larger very important pressure is required to raise working males, and to help them raise themselves, out of the varied evils, temptations, and hindrances—social, physical, and moral—which now oppress them, than is needed merely to provide certain easy needs, already felt and recognized by persons perfectly in a position and prepared to assist themselves. That drive can solely be present in great rules working by means of suitable and diversified organizations. Probably the Clubs of the higher courses might but find that they’ve an essential lesson to study from those of working men. It’s stated that many of them are already beginning to really feel the want of extra sociability among the members, of some extra definite bond of Union.

There are two sensible purposes of these views, that are comprehensive and, essential.

First,—In relation to the government and sensible conduct of Working Men’s Clubs and Institutes.

In every enterprise and establishment there have to be some governing principle, as well as some inspiring concept. Where there’s organic concord and connexion between the constituent elements, this principle, to which all questions not of mere expediency ought to be referred as to a ruler and decide, can be discovered to originate within the elementary concept. It’s so within the case of Working Men’s Clubs and Institutes. The governing principle is mutual helpfulness for the culture, advancement, and enjoyment,. (which indeed is simply a species of tradition) of all of the members. Therefore, if any query provides rise to difference of opinion in regards to the administration and operations of the Membership, the principle says, “Do that which will best promote the largest amount of culture and happiness compatable with the common consent of [page 50] the members. You are not to do that which will best promote those objects according to the views of particular individuals or sections of the Club-members, but must remember that it is a fellowship formed for mutual benefit, and that there must, therefore, be mutual concession to promote the common good. Have the largest amount of agencies and appliances for recreation, education, and social advancement that can be obtained by common consent and the constitution of your Club, but do nothing that would destroy that harmony of aim and of feeling, that balance of effort and condition, which is requisite for complete culture and associated life.”

Second,—In relation to the upkeep and usefulness of the Membership.

Here the elemental concept of a Membership clearly calls for the appliance of the precept of CO-OPERATION, which we take to be that of united contributions for proportionate income—however, in this case, income for others, and not for oneself alone. Cash, time, power, schooling, talent, and talent, must all be brought to take care of the existence and develop the usefulness of a Membership. No one should belong to it merely for the great he himself is to get out of it, but in addition for the great he is to convey into it. However, care must be taken that all, in proportion to his contributions, no matter they could be, and to his capacity for receiving, ought to be benefited by being a member of the Membership to the utmost of its functionality for good. All types of businesses will thus be brought into operation; on the one hand, to obtain for the Membership from all courses basic sympathy and assist; on the other, to make it self-supporting; but, in any case, to provide it the widest usefulness and probably the most everlasting existence.

If, in conclusion, it’s objected that we now have made the maintenance and management of these Clubs too difficult and troublesome to safe their environment friendly operation, and have set the goal and which means of them far too high to obtain for them basic help, we answer—

[page 51] First,—That the perfect means for attaining any finish are those which, whether or not difficult or simple, develop organically out of the elemental conception of the enterprise, institution, or machine, and which, subsequently, are in concord with its elements and adapted to its objects.

Second,—That Working Men’s Clubs and Institutes, in our judgment, have to be reminiscent of we’ve described, or they may ere lengthy be nothing in any respect; that if they’ve merely a body and not using a soul, they will haven’t any enduring life, and are as certain to die as any of Owen’s or Fourier’s Phalanxes; but if they have life they may inevitably grow; and then in time they may grow to be what, perhaps we rightly shrink from imagining them in their earlier levels.

Third,—That if loftiness of goal, or difficulties of execution, will preclude any essential enterprise from acquiring the sympathy and help either of the upper or of the working courses of this kingdom, we’ve totally misread the history of our nation, and misjudged our nationwide character.

Taken from Solly H. (1904) Working Men’s Social Clubs and Instructional Institutes (revised by B. T. Hall), London: Simpkin, Marshall, Hamilton, Kent and Co. First edition 1867

This piece has been reproduced here on the understanding that it isn’t subject to any copyright restrictions, and that it is, and will stay, within the public area. First placed in the archives: July 2002

Print Friendly, PDF & Email